Refresh the Brand, Maintain the Loyalty with a Strategic Packaging Rollout

In This Blog Post:

Brand equity is a perpetual dance between maintaining loyal customers and staying visually fresh enough to keep that attention and expand to new audiences. When it comes to retail aisles, the dance has become even more intricate in the past half decade.

After pandemic-era supply shortages left items missing from the shelves, roughly half of consumers reached for a different product or brand. The habit stuck. Shoppers continue to be more open to trying new brands with as much as a third exploring options outside those they usually stock.

This can make the case for a brand refresh designed to capture those wandering eyes. But with brand loyalty being more tenuous than it once was, brand managers may worry any little shift could make them invisible to those who are primed to reach for the packaging they know.

Though the concerns are warranted, they can be mitigated. A refresh done with intent deepens and expands on recognition. The work is knowing which cues to protect, which to evolve, and how to gradually get shoppers used to the new look.

A point of clarification: refresh vs. rebrand.

A brand refresh tends to happen more frequently than a complete rebrand. Most branding experts suggest a refresh every three to five years versus seven to ten for a full rebrand. While the rebrand is a much heavier lift typically involving a logo redesign, updated positioning, and maybe even a new name, the refresh is subtler. It may include a refined color palette, a logo cleanup, and a few new visual elements layered into the mix.

The packaging watchout is that while the subtle changes of a refresh are relatively easy to roll out across your website, social media, and campaigns, the split-second attention you have at the shelf complicates matters. Shoppers find your product by color, shape, and key visual elements long before they get to the name. If these recognizable components shift too much, it can be hard to hit the undo button.

Understanding the visual cues your shoppers look for.

As we just noted, most shoppers lock onto a color block, package shape, or single dominant visual before the brand name even registers. Each cue triggers recognition, but they do carry different weights.

Color plays a major role in shaping purchase intent through processing fluency. All this means is the color a shopper expects makes it easier to recognize and choose the product. In this way, even if your logo remains unchanged, minor shifts in your primary palette can confuse your loyal customers.

Still, color is one signal among many. Shape-based cues, such as brand patterns and packaging profiles, rank among the strongest assets a brand can own. The Heinz label being one of the most enduring case studies on this front. Changing the shape of your pressure sensitive label or profile of your folding carton with no bridge to other recognizable elements can break the connection a loyal shopper has to your brand.

Ultimately, a packaging refresh becomes a sorting exercise before it becomes a design exercise. Give careful consideration to shopper impact before changing primary color, structural format, dominant visual, or core hierarchy. Secondary colors, typography, supporting graphics, and finish carry less recognition weight. That’s where you have room to modernize.

The format factor: maintaining consistency where it counts.

With the shape of your packaging playing such an outsized role in brand recognition, ensuring color consistency becomes even more important if it’s determined a brand refresh also means a format change. For many brands, this is easier said than done.

A single brand color really presents multiple problems to solve depending on packaging format. The red that reads clean on a glossy pressure sensitive label can drift to a warmer tone on a matte flexible pouch and shift again on a coated folding carton. Substrate, finish, and print process each bend how the eye receives the same value. A shopper can’t name why the carton and the pouch feel slightly off from each other, but they know it does.

So the real question isn’t whether the colors of your brand refresh stay technically true to the original packaging. It’s whether they’ll stay true to the eye when a shopper encounters those same colors on a new format or material. Working with a packaging partner you can trust to achieve consistency will ensure a format shift doesn’t negatively impact loyalty.

A phased approach protects shelf presence.

A refresh doesn’t have to hit every SKU on day one. Nor should it. Sequencing is what protects your presence while the new look rolls out. Secondary packaging, direct-to-consumer options, and your lower-volume SKUs can be the perfect place to introduce consumers to the new system without staking your best-selling product on it. Save the shelf-ready packaging on your highest-volume items for last.

Some brands also choose to prototype new packaging in the wake of a brand refresh. Seeing the new look in physical form before you commit to a full run can help surface opportunities to optimize recognizable elements. You can even pressure test your prototype with actual consumers in a focus group or staged shop along to ensure the brand loyalty carries through. Once the new package has been validated, your packaging partner should be able to seamlessly bring you through to a full production run.

Signs you’re ready for the rollout.

A brand refresh is ready for shelves when a few concrete criteria line up.

• Your packaging partner understands evolved brand guidelines.
• Color consistency has been achieved across every format from labels to folding cartons.
• The new look has been validated in physical prototype.
• There’s a plan for an intentional rollout with time built in for evaluation after each phase.
• You and your packaging partner are aligned around the rollout plan and timelines.

If you can tick the box on the majority of these, you’re in a strong position to unveil your refreshed packaging to new and loyal shoppers.